As a founder member of Mystery Women in 1997, promoting Crime Fiction has always been my passion.
Following the closure of Mystery Women, a new group was formed on 30th January 2012 promoting crime fiction.
New reviews are posted daily, but to search for earlier reviews please click on the Mystery People link below and select 'reviews' from the welcome page. This will display an alphabetic option for you to find the review you would like to read
For PREVIOUS REVIEWS- Click on MYSTERY PEOPLE below -
Faber & Faber, 6 April 2017. ISBN:
Previous novels by Jean Hanff Korelitz left me admiring her ability to
portray the effect of serious crime on the people affected by it. If the crime
itself, and especially the solving of it, proved secondary to the way it
invades and damages the lives of innocent bystanders, that gave all the more
weight to the author's skill at creating and developing lead characters who
felt real, and her talent for drawing the reader into their worlds.
Reading The Devil and
Webster, however, I rapidly began to wonder if I'd wandered into a Jane
Smiley novel by mistake. Not that that's a bad thing by any means – Smiley is a
novelist who presents brilliant insight in an extremely readable way. And like
Smiley, Korelitz creates a microcosm which says a great deal not only about a
highly respected American university which finds itself in trouble, but also
about modern America in general – and also explores the effect of a difficult
and potentially explosive (though not literally) situation on the protagonist
and the people around her.
But the vexed question is, is
it a crime novel? By halfway through, the only crimes are a particularly nasty
episode of racist vandalism, and some plagiarism which lurks in the background.
After two thirds, there's a half-hearted attempt at arson. There is eventually
something more serious, but it's part of a final shocking twist and a long way
from the main focus of the narrative.
Maybe the best way to review
the book is to set that big question aside. Taken simply as a novel, regardless
of genre, it's an extremely accomplished and highly readable piece of writing.
Naomi Roth, appointed president of the prestigious Webster College some years
earlier on the back of a student 'incident' when she was in a far more junior
position, is faced with a student protest which rapidly spirals out of control
and presents the college in an unfairly bad light. Naomi, herself a veteran
student protester, is thwarted at every end and turn when she tries to find a
fair resolution to the issue – not helped by the fact that her own daughter
Hannah is a prime mover in the protest. At its centre is Omar Khayal, ostensibly
a refugee from Palestine, with a tragic history, protegé of Nicholas Gall, a
popular professor (lecturer in British terms) who has been refused tenure, and
just happens to be black. We never meet Gall, but his sacking, as the students
see it, is the focus of the protest.
What unfolds is a detailed,
careful and slightly satirical picture of American higher education, seen from
the perspective of a college president forced to face her own views, ideals and
ambitions for thecollege. Naomi emerges
as a troubled soul, well-rounded, flawed, and thoroughly sympathetic and
believable; if other characters are slightly less so, it's only because we see
them through her eyes.
I enjoyed The Devil and
Webster very much, and would recommend it highly to anyone looking for a
first-class novel about an aspect of American life. But maybe best not to make
the mistake of expecting classic features of a crime novel.
Reviewer: Lynne Patrick
Korelitzwas raised in New York City
and graduated from Dartmouth College and Clare College, Cambridge. She has
contributed articles and essays to many magazines, including Vogue, Real
Simple, Newsweek, Reader's Digest, More and Travel and Leisure (Family), and
the anthologies Modern Love and Because I Said So. She lives in Princeton, New
Jersey with her husband, Princeton professor Paul Muldoon, and their children,
and works full time as a writer and part time as a chauffeur (i.e. mom). In 2006
and 2007 she worked for Princeton's Office of Admission as an outside reader.
Lynne Patrick has been a writer ever since she could pick up a pen,
and has enjoyed success with short stories, reviews and feature journalism, but
never, alas, with a novel. She crossed to the dark side to become a publisher
for a few years, and is proud to have launched several careers which are now
burgeoning. She lives on the edge of rural Derbyshire in a house groaning with
books, about half of them crime fiction.