Published by HarperNorth,
22 October 2026.
ISBN: 978-0-00881835-7 (PB)
For the last two years Detective Inspector Tom Stonem and Detective Sergeant Lauren Rea have been involved in investigating vicious murders over the Christmas holidays and this year they are fervently hoping for a peaceful Christmas without a violent crime. This wish is soon proved to be hopeless when the police are summoned to the house of an elderly man who has been strangled. A Christmas carol is playing at full volume, and a sheet of the same music has been shoved into the victim’s mouth. The dead man is Joseph Morley who, before his retirement, had taught at St. Bartholomew’s, a local private school for boys. Morley has no living relations, apart from his ex-wife, so Tom and Lauren begin their investigations at the school, which is an impressive building, obviously tailored to the expectations of affluent parents.
The headmaster, Gareth McKenzie, had known Morley for many years because he had already been a senior teacher at the school when McKenzie had first joined the staff. He is shocked to hear of Morley’s death and explains that as well as teaching history, Morley had spent many years as choirmaster in charge of the prestigious school choir, which always gives a Christmas concert at Durham Cathedral. The headmaster tries to gloss over the more controversial aspects of Morley’s teaching methods, emphasising that earlier times involved different educational demands, but the two detectives suspect that McKenzie is trying to avoid admitting that Morley was not merely verbally abusive but also physically violent to some of the boys in the school.
McKenzie tells Tom and Lauren that the school’s reputation has been under attack from an investigative journalist, who has made podcasts that probe the case of Caleb Marshall, a fourteen-year-old boy who had disappeared from St. Bartholomew’s in 1996. At the time the police enquiry accepted the view of the then headmaster and other members of staff who maintained that Caleb had run away. However, the podcasts speak of violence, cruelty and threats within the school culture, and raise the query of why Caleb has never been seen since the night of his disappearance and, if he died through an accident or from exposure, why his body has never been discovered. This is a question that Tom and Lauren have to admit is totally valid.
Another murder takes place, which is also connected to St. Bartholomew’s school and its past. This killing is even more brutal than the first murder and Tom is aware that the killer’s violence is escalating. The pressure on Tom is growing more intense, especially when a journalist, who has got a long-standing grudge against him, makes it public that Tom and Lauren are in a relationship. They have tried to keep this private, and this public disclosure of their secret angers their senior officer. This spotlight on his professional and personal life makes Tom feel even more stressed and causes him to question his own judgment. The death toll mounts and the attacks on Tom become more personal. Soon it becomes evident that Tom’s own life is in danger and, whatever the cost to his safety and his reputation, he is determined to prevent the killer from committing an even more terrible crime.
The Christmas Carol Killer is the third book in the series featuring Tom Stonem and
Lauren Rea. Tom and Lauren are engaging protagonists, and the plot is intricate
and well-paced, with a dark theme that contrasts with the warmth and colour of
the Christmas season and the illustrious carol concert that the school choir are
scheduled to hold in the magnificent cathedral. This is a dark story that
explores what happens when the evil of the past refuses to stay buried. The
Christmas Carol Killer is an interesting read, which I recommend.
---------
Reviewer: Carol Westron
Chris Frost is a pseudonym used by Chris McDonald. He grew up in Northern Ireland and now lives in the appropriately named Marple. He is the author of ten crime books, including the Erika Piper trilogy and The Stonebridge Mysteries. He is a scriptwriter, and a regular voice on The Blood Brothers Podcast and Friends of The North. He is a fan of football, heavy metal and dogs.
Carol Westron is a Golden Age expert who has written many articles on the subject and given papers at several conferences. She is the author of several series: contemporary detective stories and police procedurals, comedy crime and Victorian Murder Mysteries. Her most recent publications are Paddling in the Dead Sea and Delivering Lazarus, books 2 and 3 of the Galmouth Mysteries, the series which began with The Fragility of Poppies. Her most recent books is The Apples of Sodom.








.jpg)

















