Recent Events

Thursday, 19 November 2026

‘The First Mistake’ by Sarah Ward.

Published by Canelo Crime,
1st October 2026. 
ISBN: 978-1-80436-939-5 (PB)

The story opens at the site of the Mari Lwyd festival taking place in Ciegwyn, a village that has a picturesque harbour, and produces delicious ice cream.  Eleri Jones has made lots of bara brith to sell by the quayside.  She is getting ready for the evening, cutting and buttering the bread and wondering where her daughter Gwennie has got to – she had promised to help but there is no sign of her. As the evening progresses and the crowds gather, Eleri is getting anxious and tries to contact Gwennie, but with no success.  Then she sees two police cars, blue lights flashing, driving along the road by the harbour. Gwennie has been attacked and, sadly, she dies in hospital, unable to give any information about the perpetrator.  

Mallory Dawson, a civilian investigator since an injury forced her to retire from the CID, is assigned to the case.  She is dismayed to discover that it is linked to her very first investigation, the murder of Gwennie’s aunt Jaci.  This has haunted her for years as there were accusations of police incompetence.  She realises that she must get things right this time, and this expectation is not made easier by having to work in a small place where the backstory is known.  As the investigation proceeds, more is discovered about the earlier case, and the police move towards identifying the killer.  But, even at this late stage, the plot still has a final twist for the reader. 

This is the fifth book in the Mallory Dawson series, and the story provides sufficient background to fill out Mallory’s personal life.  Her relationship with DI Harri Evans her boss, develops quietly in the background as they manage the personal and professional sides of their lives.  Her son is also involved, and at one point seems to be implicated in the crime. 

The complexity of having a double time-line is handled adroitly and the plot moves along at a good speed.  The effects of a serious crime on a small place and its inhabitants are brought to life as the past and present are woven together.  Readers already following the series will not be disappointed and new readers will find much to enjoy.
-------
Reviewer: Jo Hesslewood
Books by this author:  Mallory Dawson Crime Thrillers:  The Birthday Girl, The Sixth Lie, The Vanishing Act, The Death Lesson, The First Mistake:  Carla James Crime Thrillers:  Death Rites, Quiet Bones, Grave Intent

Sarah Ward is an online book reviewer whose blog, Crimepieces, reviews the best of current crime fiction published around the world. She is a judge for the Petrona Award for translated Scandinavian crime novels. Sarah lives in rural Derbyshire where her debut novel, In Bitter Chill, published by Faber and Faber, is set. Sarah has now published three further books in that series, featuring DC Childs.  She has also written five books featuring Mallory Dawson. Her most recent series features Carla James. Sarah also writes under the name of Rhiannon Ward she is the author of two gothic historical thrillers. Her first, The Quickening, was a Radio Times book of the year and The Shadowing was a Daily Express critic's favourite of 2021. 

www.crimepieces.com  

Jo Hesslewood.  Crime fiction has been my favourite reading material since as a teenager I first spotted Agatha Christie on the library bookshelves.  For twenty-five years the commute to and from London provided plenty of reading time.  I am fortunate to live in Cambridge, where my local crime fiction book club, Crimecrackers, meets at Heffers Bookshop .  I enjoy attending crime fiction events and currently organise events for the Margery Allingham Society.

No comments:

Post a Comment