Published by Four Tails Publishing,
29 December 2025.
ISBN: 978-1-990550-58-4 (PB)
The ladies of the WISE Women
Enquiries Agency are hoping for a quiet start to the New Year, because two of
their number are absent from their office in Wales Welsh village, leaving Carol
and Annie to deal with any cases that crop up. As well as working with the WISE
Women, Mavis acts as a companion to her friend Althea Twyst, the Dowager
Duchess of Chellingworth, and has accompanied her to the Twyst family home in
Scotland, so that Althea can spend time with her daughter and son-in-law, and
Mavis can visit her sons and grandchildren. Christine is staying in London with
her parents while awaiting the birth of her first child.
Annie
and Carol are asked to take on a new case, and it is one that has special
significance for Annie because it involves the therapist that had treated her
when she was traumatised after an injury. When Barbara Newsom arrives at the
office Annie is horrified because she hardly recognises the smart, competent
woman she had known. Barbara has lost a great deal of weight and appears gaunt,
frail and unkempt. Barbara tells Annie and Carol that her husband died a few
months ago; for both of them it had been a second marriage, and they each had
one adult child who did not live at home. Barbara’s late husband had been a
very wealthy man, and he had left everything to Barbara, which caused ill
feeling between Barbara and her stepson.
The
doctors have carried out several tests and have been unable to discover a
physical reason for her symptoms of nausea, weakness, fatigue and vertigo, and
Barbara is aware that these symptoms could be caused by psychological factors
following her bereavement. However, she is haunted by the fear that she is
being poisoned, presumably by someone close to her, the most likely suspect
being her daughter. Annie and Carol agree to take the case and put measures in
place to discover the truth and, if necessary, to protect Barbara.
Unfortunately, this proves very difficult when they have to cope with a client
who is torn between the necessity of safeguarding her own life, and her desire
to consolidate her relationship with her daughter, who has been unusually
attentive since Barbara’s bereavement.
As
well as this major case, Carol and Annie have other investigations to engage
their time and attention. One of these is instigated by Annie who is concerned
about the arrival of a fish and chip van that parks in the village. The chip
van’s owners charge a lot less than Tudor, Annie’s partner can ask for the
meals he serves in his pub. Annie knows
her suspicions of the new business may be fuelled by personal concerns, but she
is determined to find out all she can about the people running the chip van.
Another
personal investigation is one that they undertake at the request of Henry
Twyst, the Duke of Chellingworth. Henry is very worried that his much-loved
wife, Stephanie, is determined to improve their health by changing their diet
and enforcing more exercise. Henry feels that Stephanie is being unduly
influenced by her friend Val Jenkins, bookshop owner and nutritionist. Although
Henry does not like Val’s interference in his lifestyle, he is fond of her, and
she is the godmother of his son. This means that he is genuinely concerned when
he discovers that Val has formed a romantic attachment and gone into business
with a man that he has good reason to distrust. Stephanie does not agree with
his fears, but Henry feels so strongly about the matter that he overcomes his
natural diffidence and asks Carol to use her outstanding computer investigation
skills to check on Val’s new partner. With three cases to investigate, Carol
and Annie have a great deal to do, and while they hope that Mavis and Christine
are enjoying their break, they also feel rather overwhelmed and overworked.
However,
neither Mavis nor Christine are enjoying their time away from Wales. Mavis
finds Twyst House uncomfortable, cold and badly maintained, and the Steward in
overall charge is dour and unhelpful. In London, Christine has been confined to
bed until her baby is born and is desperately bored. She knows that she has to
take care in order to safeguard her own and the baby’s health, but that does
not stop her from feeling frustrated by her inactivity, and she misses her
fiancé, Alexander, who is trying to get all of his business interests settled,
so that he can devote himself to his family when the baby arrives. However,
even when officially off duty, both Mavis and Christine have the instinct that
discovers suspicious things to investigate, but, without her usual support
network, and with patchy internet and phone access, Mavis also discovers that
curiosity can prove very dangerous.
The
Case of the Devious Daughter is the twelfth book in the excellent
series featuring the WISE Women and it is a delightful addition to the series.
The central characters are all engaging and skilfully drawn as they change and
develop with each book. The multi-viewpoint plot is cleverly handled so that
each strand is clearly designated, but the investigations are woven together by
the close relationship of the protagonists. The Case of the Devious Daughter
is a page-turner, which I thoroughly recommend.
-------
Reviewer:
Carol Westron
Cathy Ace was born and raised in
Swansea, South Wales. With a successful career in marketing having given her
the chance to write training courses and textbooks, Cathy has now finally
turned her attention to her real passion: crime fiction. Her short stories have
appeared in multiple anthologies. Two of her works, Dear George and Domestic
Violence, have also been produced by Jarvis & Ayres Productions as
‘Afternoon Reading’ broadcasts for BBC Radio 4. Cathy now writes two series of
traditional mysteries: The Cait Morgan Mysteries (TouchWood Editions) and The
WISE Enquiries Agency Mysteries (Severn House Publishers)
http://cathyace.com
Carol
Westron is a Golden Age expert who
has written many articles on the subject and given papers at several
conferences. She is the author of several series: contemporary detective
stories and police procedurals, comedy crime and Victorian Murder Mysteries.
Her most recent publications are Paddling in the Dead Sea and Delivering Lazarus, books 2 and 3 of the
Galmouth Mysteries, the series which began with The Fragility of Poppies.